admin/HomeAudit
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
705a2757c1d7777df15717ef598cb96ed216f67f
HomeAudit/dev_documentation/migration/COMPREHENSIVE_MIGRATION_ISSUES_REPORT.md
admin 705a2757c1 Major infrastructure migration and Vaultwarden PostgreSQL troubleshooting 
COMPREHENSIVE CHANGES:

INFRASTRUCTURE MIGRATION:
- Migrated services to Docker Swarm on OMV800 (192.168.50.229)
- Deployed PostgreSQL database for Vaultwarden migration
- Updated all stack configurations for Docker Swarm compatibility
- Added comprehensive monitoring stack (Prometheus, Grafana, Blackbox)
- Implemented proper secret management for all services

VAULTWARDEN POSTGRESQL MIGRATION:
- Attempted migration from SQLite to PostgreSQL for NFS compatibility
- Created PostgreSQL stack with proper user/password configuration
- Built custom Vaultwarden image with PostgreSQL support
- Troubleshot persistent SQLite fallback issue despite PostgreSQL config
- Identified known issue where Vaultwarden silently falls back to SQLite
- Added ENABLE_DB_WAL=false to prevent filesystem compatibility issues
- Current status: Old Vaultwarden on lenovo410 still working, new one has config issues

PAPERLESS SERVICES:
- Successfully deployed Paperless-NGX and Paperless-AI on OMV800
- Both services running on ports 8000 and 3000 respectively
- Caddy configuration updated for external access
- Services accessible via paperless.pressmess.duckdns.org and paperless-ai.pressmess.duckdns.org

CADDY CONFIGURATION:
- Updated Caddyfile on Surface (192.168.50.254) for new service locations
- Fixed Vaultwarden reverse proxy to point to new Docker Swarm service
- Removed old notification hub reference that was causing conflicts
- All services properly configured for external access via DuckDNS

BACKUP AND DISCOVERY:
- Created comprehensive backup system for all hosts
- Generated detailed discovery reports for infrastructure analysis
- Implemented automated backup validation scripts
- Created migration progress tracking and verification reports

MONITORING STACK:
- Deployed Prometheus, Grafana, and Blackbox monitoring
- Created infrastructure and system overview dashboards
- Added proper service discovery and alerting configuration
- Implemented performance monitoring for all critical services

DOCUMENTATION:
- Reorganized documentation into logical structure
- Created comprehensive migration playbook and troubleshooting guides
- Added hardware specifications and optimization recommendations
- Documented all configuration changes and service dependencies

CURRENT STATUS:
- Paperless services: ✅ Working and accessible externally
- Vaultwarden: ❌ PostgreSQL configuration issues, old instance still working
- Monitoring: ✅ Deployed and operational
- Caddy: ✅ Updated and working for external access
- PostgreSQL: ✅ Database running, connection issues with Vaultwarden

NEXT STEPS:
- Continue troubleshooting Vaultwarden PostgreSQL configuration
- Consider alternative approaches for Vaultwarden migration
- Validate all external service access
- Complete final migration validation

TECHNICAL NOTES:
- Used Docker Swarm for orchestration on OMV800
- Implemented proper secret management for sensitive data
- Added comprehensive logging and monitoring
- Created automated backup and validation scripts
2025-08-30 20:18:44 -04:00

237 lines
8.6 KiB
Markdown
Raw Blame History

# COMPREHENSIVE MIGRATION ISSUES REPORT - COMPLETE
**Generated:** 2025-08-29
**Status:** INFRASTRUCTURE READY - 90% Complete
---
## 🎯 **EXECUTIVE SUMMARY**
**All critical infrastructure components are now in place and ready for service migration.** Docker Swarm is fully configured, Caddy is deployed and secured, and all services are accessible via HTTPS.
---
## 📊 **CURRENT STATUS**
### **✅ COMPLETED INFRASTRUCTURE (90%)**
- **Docker Swarm**: All 6 nodes joined and labeled ✅
- **Caddy Reverse Proxy**: Deployed and secured on surface ✅
- **Storage Configuration**: Fixed and working ✅
- **Service Analysis**: Complete with security hardening ✅
- **Node Renaming**: lenovo410 (formerly jonathan-2518f5u) ✅
- **Network Setup**: Overlay networks created ✅
- **SSL Certificates**: Automatic via DuckDNS ✅
- **Paperless Services**: Both NGX and AI deployed and running on OMV800 ✅
### **🔄 NEXT PHASE: SERVICE MIGRATION (10%)**
- **Database Services**: Deploy PostgreSQL and MariaDB
- **Service Migration**: Move services to Docker Swarm
- **Monitoring Stack**: Deploy Grafana + Netdata
- **GPU Acceleration**: Configure for Jellyfin/Immich
---
## 🏗️ **INFRASTRUCTURE STATUS**
### **Docker Swarm (COMPLETE)**
```
OMV800 (Manager) - role=storage, cpu=high, memory=high, gpu=false ✅
fedora - role=compute, cpu=medium, memory=medium, gpu=false ✅
lenovo410 - role=compute, cpu=medium, memory=medium, gpu=false ✅
audrey - role=compute, cpu=medium, memory=medium, gpu=false ✅
surface - role=compute, cpu=medium, memory=medium, gpu=false ✅
lenovo420 - role=ai-ml, cpu=high, memory=high, gpu=true ✅
```
### **Networks (COMPLETE)**
- **swarm-public**: Overlay network for service communication ✅
- **database-network**: For database services ✅
- **monitoring-network**: For monitoring services ✅
- **ingress**: For ingress traffic ✅
### **Reverse Proxy (COMPLETE)**
- **Caddy**: Running on surface (192.168.50.254) ✅
- **SSL**: Automatic certificates via DuckDNS ✅
- **Security**: High-risk services removed from external access ✅
---
## 🌐 **SERVICE STATUS**
### **Active Services (via Caddy)**
```
nextcloud.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.229:8080 (OMV800) ✅
jellyfin.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.229:8096 (OMV800) ✅
immich.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.229:2283 (OMV800) ✅
gitea.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.229:3001 (OMV800) ✅
joplin.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.229:22300 (OMV800) ✅
vikunja.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.229:3456 (OMV800) ✅
n8npressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.181:5678 (lenovo410) ✅
portainer.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.181:9000 (lenovo410) ✅
homeassistant.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.181:8123 (lenovo410) ✅
paperless.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.229:8000 (OMV800) ✅
paperless-ai.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.229:3000 (OMV800) ✅
vaultwarden.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.181:8088 (lenovo410) ✅
omnitools.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.66:9080 (lenovo420) ✅
appflowy-server.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.254:8080 (surface) ✅
dashboard.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.254:8090 (surface) ✅
uptime-kuma.pressmess.duckdns.org → 192.168.50.145:3001 (audrey) ✅
```
### **Security-Restricted Services (Local Access Only)**
- **OMV/OMV Backup**: System management interfaces ✅
- **Portainer Agent**: Docker daemon access ✅
- **Code-Server**: Full IDE access ✅
- **Dozzle**: Docker logs viewer ✅
- **AdGuard Home**: DNS filtering ✅
---
## 🔧 **RECENT FIXES APPLIED**
### **1. Docker Swarm Setup (COMPLETE)**
- ✅ **All 6 nodes joined** to swarm
- ✅ **Node labels applied** for service placement
- ✅ **Overlay networks created** for service communication
- ✅ **Node renaming** completed (lenovo410)
### **2. Caddy Deployment (COMPLETE)**
- ✅ **Corrected Caddyfile** deployed to surface
- ✅ **SSL certificates** obtained for all services
- ✅ **Security hardening** applied (removed high-risk services)
- ✅ **Service routing** configured and working
### **3. Storage Configuration (COMPLETE)**
- ✅ **Stack files updated** to use existing SMB shares
- ✅ **NFS exports** configured for service configs
- ✅ **Bind mounts** created for service directories
- ✅ **Storage paths** verified and working
### **4. Service Issues Resolved**
- ✅ **Paperless CSRF issue** fixed (updated PAPERLESS_URL and CSRF_TRUSTED_ORIGINS)
- ✅ **Service conflicts** resolved (removed Homepage, fixed port conflicts)
- ✅ **DNS resolution** working (DuckDNS updated to point to surface)
---
## 🎯 **NEXT STEPS**
### **Phase 1: Database Services (Priority 1)**
```bash
# Deploy PostgreSQL and MariaDB on OMV800
ssh root@omv800.local "cd /opt/stacks/databases && docker stack deploy -c postgresql.yml databases"
ssh root@omv800.local "cd /opt/stacks/databases && docker stack deploy -c mariadb.yml databases"
```
### **Phase 2: Service Migration (Priority 2)**
```bash
# Start with simple services first
ssh root@omv800.local "cd /opt/stacks/apps && docker stack deploy -c jellyfin.yml media"
ssh root@omv800.local "cd /opt/stacks/apps && docker stack deploy -c nextcloud.yml apps"
```
### **Phase 3: Monitoring Stack (Priority 3)**
```bash
# Deploy basic monitoring
ssh root@omv800.local "cd /opt/stacks/monitoring && docker stack deploy -c grafana.yml monitoring"
```
### **Phase 4: Optimization (Priority 4)**
- **GPU Acceleration**: Configure for Jellyfin/Immich
- **Service Distribution**: Move n8n to fedora
- **Performance Tuning**: Optimize resource allocation
---
## 📋 **DEPLOYMENT CHECKLIST**
### **✅ COMPLETED:**
- [x] Service analysis and mapping
- [x] Hardware specifications documented
- [x] End state optimization analysis
- [x] Docker Swarm setup (all nodes joined)
- [x] Node labeling for service placement
- [x] Overlay network creation
- [x] Caddy deployment and security hardening
- [x] SSL certificate generation
- [x] Service conflict resolution
- [x] Storage configuration fixes
- [x] Node renaming (lenovo410)
### **🔄 NEXT:**
- [ ] Deploy database services
- [ ] Migrate services to Docker Swarm
- [ ] Deploy monitoring stack
- [ ] Configure GPU acceleration
- [ ] Optimize service distribution
---
## 🚨 **KNOWN ISSUES**
### **Resolved Issues:**
- ✅ **Paperless CSRF**: Fixed by updating PAPERLESS_URL and CSRF_TRUSTED_ORIGINS
- ✅ **Service Conflicts**: Resolved by removing Homepage and fixing port conflicts
- ✅ **DNS Resolution**: Fixed by updating DuckDNS to point to surface
- ✅ **Storage Paths**: Fixed by updating stack files to use existing shares
### **Current Issues:**
- ⚠️ **None** - All critical infrastructure is working
---
## 📊 **PERFORMANCE METRICS**
### **Current Resource Utilization:**
- **OMV800**: 45% CPU, 20% RAM (25GB available) - UNDERUTILIZED
- **fedora**: 79% CPU, 41% RAM (8.8GB available) - MODERATE LOAD
- **lenovo410**: 74% CPU, 66% RAM (2.7GB available) - HIGH LOAD
- **surface**: 87% CPU, 29% RAM (5.5GB available) - HIGH CPU LOAD
- **lenovo420**: 27% CPU, 29% RAM (5.5GB available) - LOW LOAD
- **audrey**: 73% CPU, 30% RAM (2.6GB available) - MODERATE LOAD
### **Optimization Opportunities:**
- **OMV800**: Can handle 10+ additional services
- **fedora**: Reduce swap usage, optimize memory allocation
- **lenovo410**: Move n8n to fedora to reduce load
- **surface**: Consider moving some services to OMV800
- **lenovo420**: Well-optimized for current workload
- **audrey**: Appropriate load for monitoring role
---
## 🔒 **SECURITY STATUS**
### **External Access (via Caddy):**
- ✅ **User Services**: Nextcloud, Jellyfin, Immich, etc.
- ✅ **Monitoring**: Uptime Kuma
- ✅ **Development**: Gitea, n8n
- ✅ **IoT**: Home Assistant, ESPHome
### **Local Access Only:**
- 🔒 **System Management**: OMV, OMV Backup
- 🔒 **Container Management**: Portainer Agent
- 🔒 **Development Tools**: Code-Server, Dozzle
- 🔒 **Network Security**: AdGuard Home
---
## 📞 **SUPPORT INFORMATION**
### **Infrastructure Contacts:**
- **OMV800**: Primary storage and database host (root@192.168.50.229)
- **surface**: Caddy reverse proxy (jon@192.168.50.254)
- **lenovo410**: Home automation services (jonathan@192.168.50.181)
- **lenovo420**: AI/ML processing (jon@192.168.50.66)
- **audrey**: Monitoring services (jon@192.168.50.145)
- **fedora**: Development and automation (jonathan@localhost)
### **Access Methods:**
- **SSH**: Use inventory.ini for correct usernames
- **Web**: Services accessible via Caddy domains
- **Monitoring**: Uptime Kuma for service status
---
**Status: READY FOR SERVICE MIGRATION** 🚀
**Last Updated:** 2025-08-29
**Next Review:** After database deployment
Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink